Section 21 abolished 1 May 2026. If you’ve received a notice, your rights have changed. Find out what this means for you →

Housing4 min read30 April 2026

Is an Uncashed Cheque the Same as Returning My Deposit?

Based on: Richworth Ltd v Billingham [2023] EW Misc 8 (CC) · View judgment

The Scenario

A tenant had rented since 2011. The landlord never protected the £780 deposit. In April 2022, the landlord pushed a cheque under the door for the deposit amount, then immediately served a Section 21 notice.

The Conversation

This is how Case Buddy would handle this scenario — the same experience you get on the platform.

You

I have been renting my flat since June 2011 on an assured shorthold tenancy. My landlord never protected my deposit of £780 in a deposit protection scheme. In April 2022, the landlord shoved a cheque under my door for the deposit amount, then immediately served a Section 21 notice. I did not cash the cheque because previous ones had bounced. The landlord then closed their bank account so the cheque could not even be cashed.

Case Buddy

Thank you for explaining this. It sounds like your landlord never protected your deposit, then tried to return it via a cheque before serving a Section 21 notice — and the cheque could not be cashed. To make sure I understand fully — is the Section 21 notice still ongoing, or have court proceedings already started?

You

The landlord started court proceedings and got a possession order from a district judge. I want to know if I can appeal.

Case Buddy

Here is the legal position on your situation: Under Section 215 of the Housing Act 2004, a landlord cannot serve a valid Section 21 notice while holding a tenant's deposit that has not been protected in an authorised scheme — **unless the deposit has been returned to the tenant**. The critical question in your case is whether delivering an uncashed cheque counts as "returning" the deposit. The legal position is: - An uncashed cheque does **not** automatically constitute return of the deposit — this is a question of fact in each case - If the cheque could not be cashed (because previous cheques bounced and the account was then closed), the deposit has not been effectively returned - If the deposit was neither protected nor effectively returned, the Section 21 notice is **invalid** and cannot be relied upon for possession Regarding an appeal: - If the district judge made a possession order based on an invalid Section 21 notice, there may be grounds to appeal - Appeals from district judge decisions go to a circuit judge - There are strict time limits for appealing (usually 21 days from the order) You may also have a separate claim for compensation of up to 3 times the deposit amount for the landlord's failure to protect it. For free specialist advice, contact Shelter on 0808 800 4444 or a housing solicitor urgently given the appeal time limits. *This is legal information, not legal advice. For advice specific to your circumstances, consult a qualified solicitor.*

The Correct Legal Position

  • Under s.215 Housing Act 2004, a landlord cannot serve a valid s.21 notice while holding an unprotected deposit, unless the deposit has been returned to the tenant.
  • An uncashed cheque does not automatically constitute return of the deposit — it is a question of fact.
  • If the deposit has not been effectively returned and was never protected, the s.21 notice is invalid.
  • The tenant may also claim compensation of up to 3x the deposit for failure to protect it.

What the Court Decided

The appeal was allowed and the district judge's possession order was set aside. The court found the uncashed cheque did not constitute return of the deposit.

Important: This case study is for educational purposes only. Case Buddy provides legal information, not legal advice. Every situation is different — for advice specific to your circumstances, consult a qualified solicitor. Free advice is available from Shelter (housing), ACAS (employment), and StepChange (debt).

Facing a similar situation?

Describe your situation to Case Buddy and get free legal information tailored to your facts.

Start a Free Case

Stay informed

Get legal tips and Case Buddy updates delivered to your inbox.